ADD ANI AS A TRUSTED SOURCE
googleads
Menu
Middle East

Raising questions, UN agency cuts in half the number of women, children killed in Gaza

A United Nations agency tracking Gaza's casualty figures reduced by half the number of women and children killed in the Strip since October 7, raising questions about conflict's true death toll.

ANI May 14, 2024 07:18 IST googleads

Representative Image (Photo/TPS)

Tel Aviv [Israel], May 14 (ANI/TPS): A United Nations agency tracking Gaza's casualty figures reduced by half the number of women and children killed in the Strip since October 7, raising questions about conflict's true death toll.
An infographic published by the UN's Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) on May 8 indicated that 4,959 women and 7,797 children have been killed in Gaza since October 7. That was half the number indicated on a May 6 infographic which reported 9,500 women and 14,500 children had been killed.
Both infographics sourced the figures to "Gaza HMO" or Health Ministry officials. Gaza's Health Ministry is run by the Hamas terror group.
OCHA did not offer any explanation for the dramatic revision. OCHA's figures are widely sourced by international leaders, diplomats, the media and humanitarian aid organizations.
Israel's war against Hamas is now in its eighth month and the casualty figures have not been independently verified.
Israelis have questioned the numbers, pointing out that the Gaza Health Ministry is run by Hamas, and has a record from previous conflicts of blurring distinctions between civilian and combatant casualties, or attributing natural deaths to Israeli operations.
More recently, critics have raised issues with statistical anomalies, pointing out that Hamas's claim that 70 per cent of the victims are women and children is statistically impossible.
On April 6, the Hamas-run Health Ministry announced on its Telegram channel that it had "incomplete" data on one-third of the casualties. In response, experts told The Press Service of Israel that Hamas's announcement needed to be treated with skepticism, and that the true number of Palestinian civilians killed in the conflict may never be known.
"The idea in psychological warfare is to get the enemy always on the worrying side, to shake its confidence and power. The Palestinians have lied all throughout the conflict with Israel. They lie about the number of Palestinians living in the West Bank, they lie about the Palestinians living in Gaza, they lie as a system," Dr. Ron Schleifer told TPS-IL at the time.
Schleifer, who teaches communications at Ariel University said, "If you don't want to call them liars, they're inconsistent and dubious. But the idea is the same. You inflate your numbers depending on what image you want. You can lie to show weakness when weakness is the winning argument. That's when they inflate the numbers of people killed. The inflated death toll is an element of psychological warfare."
The revised figures also raise questions about OCHA. On Wednesday, TPS-IL exposed how the agency is republishing Hamas propaganda through reports written by Euro-Med Human Rights Monitor, whose current and former directors have been identified as Hamas operatives.
The reports, seen by TPS-IL accuse Israel of "genocide," organ theft, using banned thermal weapons, burying Palestinians in mass graves, massacring Palestinians in Gaza's Shifa Hospital, deliberately using Palestinians as human shields, and sexually assaulting Palestinian women. These reports are published on Relief Web, an information portal overseen by OCHA and widely used by the international humanitarian community.
At least 1,200 people were killed and 240 Israelis and foreigners were taken hostage in Hamas's attacks on Israeli communities near the Gaza border on October 7. Around 30 of the remaining 132 hostages are believed dead. (ANI/TPS)

Get the App

What to Read Next

US

FBI Director Kash Patel on Michigan Synagogue incident

FBI Director Kash Patel on Michigan Synagogue incident

"FBI personnel are on the scene with partners in Michigan and responding to the apparent vehicle ramming and active shooter situation out of Temple Israel Synagogue in West Bloomfield Township, Michigan. @FBIDetroit," Patel posted on X, adding that the bureau's FBI Detroit Field Office was involved in the response.

Read More
Asia

"India harnessed digital tools to expand...": MEA Secy (West)

George highlighted how digital tools and AI empower 1.4 billion Indians.

Read More
Asia

PM Modi speaks to Iranian President Pezeshkian

PM Modi speaks to Iranian President Pezeshkian

"Had a conversation with Iranian President, Dr. Masoud Pezeshkian, to discuss the serious situation in the region. Expressed deep concern over the escalation of tensions and the loss of civilian lives as well as damage to civilian infrastructure," PM Modi posted on X.

Read More
Asia

India consistently supported Maldives in crisis: Mohamed Nasheed

India consistently supported Maldives in crisis: Mohamed Nasheed

He highlighted India's role as a "first responder" for the Maldives, emphasising that India's support during critical periods has been fundamental to the stability and security of the island nation.

Read More
Asia

MoCA closely monitoring air travel situation in West Asia

MoCA closely monitoring air travel situation in West Asia

The Ministry of Civil Aviation is closely monitoring the evolving situation in the West Asia region and its impact on air travel between India and countries in the region. Airlines are undertaking necessary operational adjustments in view of the prevailing conditions to ensure passenger safety and the orderly conduct of flight operations.

Read More
Home About Us Our Products Advertise Contact Us Terms & Condition Privacy Policy

Copyright © aninews.in | All Rights Reserved.